
Writer/director Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck sought to make a film that echoed the constant, chilling paranoia of East Germany before the fall of the Berlin Wall. He succeeded brilliantly.
The Lives of Others is a tense film executed with quiet power. Set in 1984 East Berlin, it focuses on Stasi officer Gerd Wiesler (Ulrich Muehe), one of the best in the German Secret Police. Right away, you can tell that he’s a man whose life is his job and vice versa.
While we’ve seen this kind of character time and time again in American cinema, Muehe excels in bringing subtleties that transform the character from a stereotype to a complex individual. Despite a quiet demeanor and apparent lack of emotion, it’s clear that his passion is serving the GDR.
Minister Bruno Hempf (Thomas Thieme) orders Wiesler to set up surveillance of a famous playwright Georg Dreyman (Sebastian Koch). Though Wiesler has his own suspicions initially (artists were dangerous free-thinkers, after all), he soon discovers the true purpose of the operation is to get dirt on Dreyman so the Minister can take Dreyman’s girlfriend, a celebrated actress. Thieme plays a grimy politician with disturbing accuracy.
The seed of doubt planted, Wiesler begins to question what it means to serve the GDR, what it means to be a Stasi officer, and what it means to be loveless and unloved.
Each time Wiesler returns to his huddle of machines and microphones in the attic above Dreyman’s apartment, you’re as riveted as he is. He becomes a third occupant of the apartment. Muehe’s subtle performance leaves a strong impact, and it breaks your heart to watch this hardened policeman learn to feel.
Muehe’s performance is doubly fascinating considering that he himself was the target of Stasi operations while growing up in East Berlin.
While Muehe is the focus of this film, it’s not for lack of quality elsewhere. The script is beautifully written -- which you can’t help but notice when you’re reading subtitles -- and every actor delivers a stellar performance.
Why did this movie win the 2007 Best Foreign Film Oscar and multitudes of other awards? Because it has a haunting timelessness despite its very specific period setting, and manages to leave you both heartbroken and hopeful.
You don’t want to miss this one.
Check out the website to learn more about the film: it's almost as well-done as the movie.